diff --git a/src/EventHandler/Channel/ChannelParticipant.php b/src/EventHandler/Channel/ChannelParticipant.php
index ed18c18fa..9de86cade 100644
--- a/src/EventHandler/Channel/ChannelParticipant.php
+++ b/src/EventHandler/Channel/ChannelParticipant.php
@@ -19,7 +19,6 @@ namespace danog\MadelineProto\EventHandler\Channel;
 use danog\MadelineProto\EventHandler\ChatInvite;
 use danog\MadelineProto\EventHandler\Participant;
 use danog\MadelineProto\EventHandler\Participant\Left;
-use danog\MadelineProto\EventHandler\Participant\Member;
 use danog\MadelineProto\EventHandler\Update;
 use danog\MadelineProto\MTProto;
 
@@ -70,6 +69,6 @@ final class ChannelParticipant extends Update
         // if null, user joind
         $this->newParticipant = isset($rawChannelParticipant['new_participant'])
             ? Participant::fromRawParticipant($rawChannelParticipant['new_participant'])
-            : new Member(['user_id' => $this->userId, 'date' => $this->date]);
+            : new Left(['peer' => $this->userId]);
     }
 }